Analysis of “The Singer Solution To World Poverty” Essay

A Critique For â€Å"The Singer Solution To World Poverty† In the essay â€Å"The Singer Solution to World Poverty,† philosopher Peter Singer addresses the issue of poverty by suggesting Americans give away most of their income to aid those in need. Singer believes that withholding income is the equivalence of letting a child starve to death. Therefore, Singer suggests the ethical thing to do to end world hunger is to give up everyday luxuries. Although donating a vast amount of money could help dying and starving children, Singer’s proposition is not only unrealistic but also too demanding for everyday Americans who have responsibilities of their own. Singer begins his essay with Dora, a schoolteacher, who sells an orphan awaiting to have†¦show more content†¦Singer uses Bob and Dora, two individuals who chose money and objects over children, and compares them to his audience. He even goes as far as to compare the lack of help Americans give starving children in Africa to Nazi Germany and those who did nothing to sto p the Third Reich. He bases his logic on what the moral thing to do is. Singer attempts to guilt trip his readers by giving examples of life and death situations, in which lay in the hands of immoral people. Although Singer does mean well and wants to make a difference for those whose lives are at risk, his solution to is too demanding for everyday people and his authoritative deliverance in not very persuasive. Furthermore, Singer not only expects too much, but doesn’t realize luxuries and necessities mean different things to different people. Singer overwhelms the reader by stating one number to expecting a lot more. Singer fails to mention how much people struggle in America alone. Sure, it would be great to end world hunger, but what about giving to those in need in the US? According to Unicef, the United States has the second highest population of child poverty in the list of developed countries, (Unicef). Although it would be wonderful to be able to help all in need, so metimes it isn’t possible when Americans are struggling themselves to pay bills and raise their own. In conclusion, although Singer does have a good meaning behind his essay, he fails to persuade his audience by being too demanding.Show MoreRelatedAnalysis Of The Article The Singer Solution And World Poverty By Peter Singer1087 Words   |  5 PagesChioma Obi Professor White English 1301-81002 25 September 2017 The Right Thing to Do: Ending Poverty The article, â€Å"The Singer Solution to World Poverty,† by Peter Singer provides the argument that Americans should spend some of their income to help those in need, instead of using it on luxuries that they don’t need. Singer supports his argument by indicating that we are somewhat like the characters in the story. I have mixed feelings with Singer’s claim because he expects that people have moneyRead MoreAnalysis Of Rich And Poor By Peter Singer1052 Words   |  5 PagesRhetorical Analysis of â€Å"Rich and Poor† We all heard countless solutions on how to solve world poverty. In Peter Singer’s article â€Å"Rich and Poor†, he discusses how he thinks this problem can be fixed. Singer claims that we all have a responsibility to support people who are in extreme need and are suffering from absolute poverty. Singer believes that poverty could be fixed if people give up their luxuries and give the money that they spent on unnecessary things to those who are destitute. In Singer s mindRead MoreQuestions On Ethics And Human Sciences1423 Words   |  6 PagesOne of the important issues discussed nowadays is the World Poverty. There are many disagreements between experts in this domain, whether rich nations are morally obligated to help poor nations, whether helping the Poor by giving them fish instead of a fishing rods is a good solution? The question is why these disagreements occur? My main thesis is that disagreements between experts occur because of three main reasons, first of al l each of expert can use different ways of knowing in order to exploreRead MoreRhetorical Analysis Of Peter Singer s The Singer Solution1495 Words   |  6 PagesRhetorical Analysis of Peter Singer’s ‘The Singer Solution to World Poverty† From the streets of New York, to the mud homes in South Africa, poverty is a problem the world has been facing since the beginning. We see people pushing buggies full of items from their past lives, or we see children on the television struggling to survive due to the lack of food or clean water in their country. Yet, only a handful of us actually defend these children in a world that heavily depends on the idea that peopleRead MoreThe Mind Body Problem Of The Chinese Room Experiment1179 Words   |  5 Pagesunderstand the world through science. Science is able to create illusions and manifest many faulty ideas which can be believed as true. Consciousness allows individuals to think and question if what is seen before then actually exists. 3. There is an unstated obligation that we as Americans have in order to end starvation and in doing so, we must minimize the amount of spending done on luxury items and use a partial amount of that disposable income to aid in ending starvation. Singer outlines theRead MorePeter Singer s And Onora O Neill s Essay1566 Words   |  7 PagesPeter Singer’s and Onora O’Neill’s attempt to draw connection between poverty and moral philosophy and how aid should be directed towards groups in absolute poverty. The aim of this paper is to provide an extensive analysis on the work of both the philosophers’ while outlining some of the limitations each of the theories has. Peter Singer is an Australian philosopher who has written extensively on poverty and social issues. Peter Singer states that â€Å"giving to charity† or neither charitable nor generous;Read MoreThe Case Against Helping The Poor2052 Words   |  9 Pageshopes of persuading his readers to oppose altruism. Similarly, in â€Å"The Singer Solution to World Poverty,† Peter Singer presents his readers with two hypothetical scenarios to urge his audience to contemplate their own responsibilities in helping third world children. After initially reading these two articles the reader might think that these authors have two clearly different views on the matter of altruism. However, a close analysis of both Hardin and Singer’s use of imaginary scenarios reveals a skewedRead MoreEssay on Duty versus Charity: Why a Distinction is Essential1256 Words   |  6 Pagescountry of Bangladesh) was undergoing a severe famine, due to rampant poverty, a civil war and frequent cyclones . The lack of overseas help to this impoverished region was probably what triggered Peter Singer to write the article Famine, Affluence and Morality, wherein he claims that world hunger and famine can be prevented and possibly eradicated if everyone in the wealthy nations did their bit to help the sufferers monetarily. Singer further claims that duty and charity should not be as distinct asRead MoreThe Rich Mans Debt : Ethical Obligations1537 Words   |  7 Pagespoor and on what grounds said duty is justified. This inquiry prompts an ethical analysis of the world order’s role, as well as individual institution’s role in worsening or failing to improve the living conditions of impoverished countries. The Western developed countries have an unquestionable ethical obligation to provide significant financial aid to the global poor. In this paper, I will demonstrate both the world order’s and private institution’s culpability in creating the increased poor-r ichRead MoreLifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor - Garrett Hardin What Should A Billionaire Give-and What Should You? - Peter Singer3380 Words   |  14 PagesLifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor - Garrett Hardin What Should A Billionaire Give-and What Should You? - Peter Singer One of the most important issues facing the world today is the issue of the poor. There are many things that can be done about this issue, however much of the world is torn between wanting to help and not knowing how to go about it. This is the issue that is presented in the two essays - Garrett Hardin’s â€Å"Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor,† and